Key takeaways:
- A handful of large vision insurance companies dominate the market, and lawmakers have repeatedly examined whether their practices are anticompetitive.
- There is a growing trend of consolidation and vertical integration in the vision industry that doesn’t benefit patients.
- As a broker, you can help preserve a fair market where patients have access to affordable care by being mindful of the plans you offer.
Did you know that two companies control 85% of market shares for stand-along vision insurance plans? Concentration on that scale, combined with vertical integration, creates an environment that hurts competition.
For consumers, this means fewer choices and potentially higher premiums and other costs. As a broker, it’s important to be aware of this issue and clarify your position regarding practices that can hurt consumers.
Consolidation and Vertical Integration in the Vision Insurance Industry
In February 2026, the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform asked the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission for briefings on their efforts to monitor and prevent anticompetitive consolidation in vision care.
Consolidation and vertical integration have been a growing trend in the vision industry. It’s unclear if antitrust laws will target the industry in the future
Vertical Integration: Why It Hurts the Vision Industry
Before going any further, it’s important to understand what vertical integration is and how it affects you and your customers:
- A few large companies dominate the majority of the vision insurance market.
- They’ve been buying or partnering with optometrists, labs, and manufacturers to build a system that controls the entire process, from purchasing insurance to receiving care.
Once an insurance company controls an entire vertical, it can use coverage limitations to force consumers to make the choices that benefit the insurer the most. This can look like:
- Limiting access to independent optometrists in favor of the retailers with which the insurance company has partnered.
- Imposing lab restrictions so that consumers must obtain glasses and lenses from the lab owned by the insurer.
With this system in place, consumers are stuck in a vertical controlled by their insurer. This limits choices and competition, and puts the insurer in a position to raise prices.
What Vertical Integration and Consolidation Mean for Consumers
Vision Benefit Managers (VBMs) use vertical control to steer patients toward the businesses they own or partner with. In practice, that means VBMs can:
- Force consumers into in-network retail chains.
- Restrict access to independent optometrists.
- Mandate that patients purchase lenses and frames through insurer-owned labs.
Independent practices can offer an alternative, but competition is tough. In areas with few options, consumers are stuck with the prices dictated by retail chains.
Why Vision Insurance Antitrust Matters to Brokers
As a broker, you get to pick which insurance companies you work with. Repeated scrutiny of anticompetitive vision practices should be a wake-up call if you’re working with major insurance providers.
Creating a market with fewer choices for consumers isn’t in your best interest. At the end of the day, consumers stuck in a vertical and paying more for services will have a low satisfaction rate.
There is an opportunity to build trust with your audience and maximize value by:
- Discussing vertical integration and anticompetitive practices when reviewing plans.
- Offering a wide range of options to preserve consumers’ choices and fair competition in vision plans.
- Prioritizing plans that give your customers access to independent optometry practices.
- Reviewing pricing models carefully to understand coverage limitations for the plans you offer.
- Paying close attention to networks and going over which local practices accept the plans your customers are interested in.
As lawmakers continue to examine consolidation in vision care, anticompetitive practices are getting attention in the media, and you’re more likely to run into consumers who are aware of the issue. Congress has looked into the issue several times over the years, and there has also been pushback from other industry players in the form of lawsuits.
For brokers who position themselves as being against these practices, there is a real opportunity to stand out.
From Controversial Practices to Differentiator
Prioritizing plans from large vision insurance companies can be tempting. However, you can stand out from competitors by taking a different approach:
- Build a portfolio that includes plans from smaller insurance companies. Providing your customers with more choices will boost their satisfaction.
- Prioritize products that don’t limit choices. It aligns with the patient-centric care trend shaping vision health and encourages your customers to play a more active role in their health journey.
- Protect independent optometry access as much as you can. These small practices provide excellent patient care and are likely to contribute to a high satisfaction rate.
Not every plan that looks competitive on paper gives members real choice. Before you recommend a plan, ask the carrier about:
- Lab access: Can members use any lab, or must glasses and lenses come from an insurer-owned lab?
- Independent providers: How many independent optometry practices are in-network in your clients’ area, not just statewide?
- Retail ties: Can frame and lens allowances be used anywhere, or only at affiliated retail chains?
- Pricing transparency: Are member costs clear up front, or do they change depending on where the patient shops?
- Network stability: How often do local practices leave the network, and how are members notified?
This approach will help you connect with customers who want more choices, care about value, or who have had bad experiences with major insurance providers in the past. It also helps you become a trusted advisor who can assist customers in navigating a complex market where pricing and fairness are growing concerns.
Who Values Vision Insurance Choices the Most?
Some clients feel the effects of vertical integration more than others. They are often the most receptive to a broader portfolio:
- Employers in rural and small-town areas: When the nearest in-network retail chain is far away, a plan that includes local independent practices makes the benefit usable.
- Groups with a trusted local eye doctor: Employees who already have a long-standing relationship with an optometrist don’t want to give it up because of a plan change.
- Clients who had a bad experience with a major carrier: Surprise costs can make clients more open to alternatives.
- Cost-conscious employers:. Clients watching premiums closely appreciate a broker who explains where costs come from, not just what they are.
How to Make this Approach a Part of Your Brand
Once your portfolio reflects these values, say so. A few practical ways to do it:
- Describe your approach on your website, for example as a commitment to plans that protect access to independent eye care.
- Add a short section to your proposals comparing lab access, network makeup, and allowance flexibility side by side.
- Mention new independent-friendly options in renewal emails and client newsletters.
- Share local stories, with permission, of clients who kept their own eye doctor after switching plans.
Keep the message positive. Focus on what your recommended plans offer, such as choice, transparency, and local access, rather than criticizing specific carriers. Clients respond better to a clear benefit than to a warning, and it keeps your relationships across the industry intact.
How Unity Vision Supports a Fair Market
Anticompetitive practices affect everyone in the industry. As a broker, you can make a difference and help preserve a fair market where customers have access to affordable care by being mindful of the products you offer.
Unity Vision is on your side with doctor-owned plans that prioritize patients’ needs. We don’t restrict lab choices and give your customers access to one of the largest networks of optometrists in the state, including many independent practices.
Everything is transparent, and your customers have full control over the care they receive. You can expect improved satisfaction and products that support a fair and competitive industry for everyone.
Learn more about becoming a Unity Vision broker here.
FAQ
What is vertical integration in the vision insurance industry?
Major vision insurance providers have been buying and partnering with downstream businesses. The goal is to force customers to select specific optometrists, labs, and manufacturers, thereby benefiting the insurance company.
How is consolidation hurting patients in the eye health industry?
Consolidation creates fewer choices and limits competition. It means prices increase, and patients may not have access to the care they need. In areas with few options, patients are often stuck with the prices set by retail chains.
What can brokers do against anticompetitive practices in the vision industry?
As a broker, you can make a difference by working with smaller insurance companies. Offering diverse options and helping customers understand costs and coverage limitations are also important.
What is a Vision Benefit Manager (VBM)?
A Vision Benefit Manager is a company that administers vision insurance benefits on behalf of employers and health plans. Many of the largest VBMs also own or are affiliated with eyewear manufacturers, optical labs, and retail chains, which gives them influence over nearly every step of a patient’s vision care.
How concentrated is the vision insurance market?
Two companies control 85 percent of the market shares for stand-alone vision insurance plans. In many states, a single company holds most of the market, which leaves employers and consumers with few real alternatives.
Why are lawmakers concerned about vision insurance consolidation?
Lawmakers have raised concerns that VBMs may be using their size and vertical integration to steer patients toward affiliated businesses, raise costs, and reduce competition. Congress has examined the issue several times, and some lawmakers have compared these practices to those of Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) in the prescription drug market.
How does vertical integration affect independent optometrists?
Independent optometrists can be pushed out of networks, offered lower reimbursements, or required to send eyewear orders to insurer-owned labs. Over time, this makes it harder for small practices to compete, and patients can lose access to the eye doctor they know and trust.
Do patients pay more because of consolidation in the vision insurance industry?
When one company controls the insurance, the lab, and the retail location, there is less pressure to keep prices low. Patients in areas with few options are especially exposed, since they have little choice but to accept the prices set by in-network retail chains.